Recent Comments

Fiat's Motherhood rap and Tom Fletcher's wedding speech top the Viral Video Charts

Fiat's Motherhood rap and Tom Fletcher's wedding speech top the Viral Video Charts

Shame the Fiat ad is a shameless rip off of earlier Toyota work.

http://youtu.be/ql-N3F1FhW4


10 Jan 2013 - 13:55
The Marketing Weak Award: Go Outdoors - Walking The Dog

The Marketing Weak Award: Go Outdoors - Walking The Dog

No, The Drum doesn't need a committee to decide an ad is poor. It's a piece of editorial and it's entitled to it's opinion, as am I. I think the ad is an absolute turd, and I don't need to run it past some hypothetical committee to be entitled to say so - neither does The Drum.

Incidentally, I don't know if you ever read Campaign but you'll find the "active critique" as you put it is actually shorter and less detailed than the one offered here.

* This post was approved by The Drum Comments Section Approval Committee.


30 Nov 2012 - 11:25
Ad of the Day: Wild Turkey Bourbon - Bird Up

Ad of the Day: Wild Turkey Bourbon - Bird Up

How did that get past ClearCast?


29 Nov 2012 - 14:27
The Marketing Weak Award: Go Outdoors - Walking The Dog

The Marketing Weak Award: Go Outdoors - Walking The Dog

We need a committee now to decide if an ad is bad?


28 Nov 2012 - 22:26
The Marketing Weak Award: Go Outdoors - Walking The Dog

The Marketing Weak Award: Go Outdoors - Walking The Dog

Isn't that what editorial is for? So you can have an opinion based on your own opinion?

Can we stop pretending there's something wrong with criticising work? We've all done it.

Campaign does a column called Private view which critiques ads too. Maybe you should complain about that?


28 Nov 2012 - 18:04

Pages