29 March 2011 - 9:15am | posted by | 4 comments

Gordon Young's Leader: why the creative industry should not rely on likes of V+M

Gordon Young's Leader: why the creative industry should not rely on likes of V+MGordon Young's Leader: why the creative industry should not rely on

Rob Morrice of IAS b2b Marketing caused a stir yesterday by arguing the media and marketing industry should stop abdicating responsibility for its future to the public sector. Gordon Young agrees.

How many publicly funded initiatives aimed at helping the creative industries prosper has The Drum reported on over the last 25 years?

Dozens. And dozens. In fact too many to count. Scottish Design, the Creative Industries Development Services, Creative Edinburgh and the aptly named Wealth in Design (WIND) have all come and gone on our watch for example.

And with the latest round of Government cuts a few more – like initiatives run by North West Vision & Media – are about to bite the dust.

As a result now would be a good juncture to ask if the countless £millions invested in such projects has been well spent.

The toddlers of today – who will ultimately pay for them – may want to know what legacy the schemes have left behind. What exactly will they get out of them?

The answer may well be not a lot.  The initiatives these organisations instigate rarely outlast the organisations themselves. When the public money dries up so does the enthusiasm of their supporters.

Take Vision & Media's Resign London campaign. Or its initiative to persuade more clients to use North West agencies. Both have been strangled at birth along with several other high-profile schemes now the budgets have been cut.

Rob Morrice, the managing director of IAS was on the V&M steering committee designed to attract clients into the North West.

And yesterday he called for the industry to stop relying on the public sector and to start helping itself. A good start, he said would be to complete the client initiative under its own steam.

His call to action deserves support. If it can build momentum, a scheme run by the industry for the industry would stand a far higher chance of making a difference and leaving a lasting legacy than one run by civil servants.

Ronald Reagan once famously said the most feared words in the English language were 'I'm from the Government. I'm here to help.'

He was right. Ironically if the rumpus surrounding V&M does provide a catalyst that galvanises the industry into helping itself that might not be a bad legacy in its own right.  Perhaps, by accident they have hit on a better model for public sector intervention.


Anonymous (not verified)
29 Mar 2011 - 09:45
Anonymous's picture

Correction: The initiatives these organisations instigate rarely outlast the obligatory drinks reception and post-conference networking event (inevitably attended by people even less qualified than you to help the industry).

29 Mar 2011 - 10:24
victor_brierley's picture

Erm Hello??? Is anyone there? If you read the comment I left on Rob Morrice's rant. you'll see there's a HUGE issue that everyone's ignoring. As our Industry Spokesman. it's your job to give David Cameron a verbal doing. If I see him, I'll be a bit more physical. like an egg in his coupon or a Jeremy Clarkson-style custard pie in his smarmy face.

Bring back Maggie Thatcher!

Anonymous (not verified)
29 Mar 2011 - 10:49
Anonymous's picture

Victor, now you've had your childish rant, why don't you enlighten us all as to how we should achieve all this.

Maybe we should establish an industry body, which represents our industry with credibility, is supported by the major players, and staffed by industry experts who have top class pedigrees, are high profile, and have serious heavyweight clout?

Oh yes, in other words the IPA!

Maybe if we all started to support them more, we could make this body even more effective.

So Victor, I suggest you give Hamish Pringle a call and have a chat. He's a lovely man, and instead of talking and whining about things, actually spends his days trying to achieve something tangible to benefit and protect our industry.

Anonymous (not verified)
29 Mar 2011 - 14:56
Anonymous's picture

Mr Arden, there must be at least another 14 or 15 discussion topics on here, that you haven't posted your self-promotion on.

Hurry up, or else some other ageing opportunist might beat you to the punch!


Please sign in or register to comment on this article.

Latest Projects from the Profile Hub

Search campaign increases revenue by 492%

Hobbycraft had been investing in PPC for a while, but spend...

PG tips

The definitive article Decades of evolutionary pack changes...

Raise a glass to Private Dining Room's online visibility

Private Dining Rooms, an online venue finder, initially...

Wigmore Hall

BRIEF Having worked with Wigmore Hall in the past, we were...

172% increase in non-brand profit year-on-year for Virgin Holidays

Virgin Holidays is the largest transatlantic tour operator...