The Drum Awards Festival - Extended Deadline

-d -h -min -sec


Good call: Four ways to sharpen your decision-making

By Damon McCollin-Moor, Strategy director



The Drum Network article

This content is produced by The Drum Network, a paid-for membership club for CEOs and their agencies who want to share their expertise and grow their business.

Find out more

October 4, 2018 | 5 min read

The power of persuasion

decision making

A study from Columbia University found that on average, most people are stalled by more than 70 decisions a day. Every day. All across the land, marketers are crafting plans designed to persuade, cajole and coax their target audiences to experience this sentiment or to take that action. After all, the art of influence is a key part of our arsenal; we understand the levers that can be pulled and the dials that can be turned to help shape the decision-making process.

While we are (rightly) focused on the factors that influence the decisions made by our customers and prospective customers, are we applying similar levels of thought to how we arrive at our own choices? When formulating marketing strategies, are we interrogating our own decision-making processes enough?

When it comes to your own strategic planning and thinking, the following techniques and theories could reinvigorate your approach to decision-making:

1. Make a decision about the decision

Before approaching the decision itself, it’s essential to understand the parameters of what’s in front of you. How urgent is it? How much does it matter? Does it have implications for anything or anybody else? What are the potential consequences? Can they be undone? Decisions about where to invest your life savings and what to have for lunch are very different but, more to the point, they don’t (or certainly shouldn’t) carry equal importance so some perspective is needed. The trusty Pareto Principle tells us that 80% of our rewards will be generated by just 20% of our efforts – at the same time warning that 80% of our efforts will deliver a return of just 20%. This ratio provides a sound, simple framework for evaluating and prioritising your decision-making. Using Pareto Analysis, you are left with a clearer sense of the 20% of decisions that deserve 80% of your time and attention.

2. Ask the data

Not too long ago, Big Data was being hailed as the answer to almost all the business world’s problems. The volume of the rhetoric has since been turned down but the principle remains: companies today have an ever-expanding range of rich information sources at their fingertips, and by harnessing those sources, and extracting and analysing the data within, they can open up a veritable goldmine of insight. This data-driven decision-making (DDDM) process relies on hard figures and the ability to extrapolate them into probable outcomes via analysis tools. For today’s marketers looking on the hunt for answers, stopping to ask the data - a fundamental source of decision-making evidence - provides a solid foundation for understanding customer behaviour. It also adds a scientific backbone to complement other approaches, such as...

3. Listen to your gut

In a data-driven world, it’s easy to dismiss or devalue your gut feelings as irrational, unstructured thought bombs. But those mid-shower, flashbulb moments of enlightenment can reveal true genius. Unconscious thought theory (UTT) puts forward the idea that our unconscious mind is actually better at solving complex tasks than conscious thought. As such, there is an argument for giving ourselves the time and space to review, digest and incubate ideas rather than press for an immediate solution – I’m sure we’ve all felt the discomfort of being trapped in a brainstorm meeting that has long-since flatlined. With a little more patience and more consideration for the power of our unconscious minds, we should trust that our intellect, experience and understanding will all culminate in that unscheduled 'Eureka!' moment.

4. Know your enemy

Perhaps most important of all is to learn and understand the biases that, unbeknown to us, influence our decision-making processes. In recent years, marketers have become increasingly aware of the risk of unconscious bias, particularly on issues around diversity and inclusivity. There is also now a louder conversation around cognitive biases – the broad range of effects, laws and fallacies that, unless we know more about them, threaten to impair the clarity of our thinking.

To keep ourselves more in line, perhaps the answer is to infuse our thinking more with the spirit of the challenging/inquisitive toddler, perpetually asking ‘why?’ Taking the time openly question and honestly answer questions about what is driving us, as marketers, to follow a certain strategy or use a particular approach can give us new perspectives and inspire fresh thinking.

Maybe chucking in two or three juicy ‘but why ?’ interruptions into every marketing meeting is the way to ensure campaigns have more impact and to achieve marketing greatness. Who knows? We’ll let you decide.

While it may feel counterintuitive, making more decisions (about your decisions) could be the the key to sailing through those 70 decisions a day, and getting others to do the same for your brands and products.

Damon McCollin-Moore, strategy director, ifour


Content by The Drum Network member:


create clever ®

ifour is a multiple award-winning creative agency based in Tunbridge Wells, Kent. Founded by Creative Director, Graeme Hall. His vision was...

Find out more

More from Advertising

View all


Industry insights

View all
Add your own content +