Yawn

Punters don't care if I embezzle the company accounts either, Gerry. Doesn't mean it's ok.

Shame the Fiat ad is a shameless rip off of earlier Toyota work.

http://youtu.be/ql-N3F1FhW4

No, The Drum doesn't need a committee to decide an ad is poor. It's a piece of editorial and it's entitled to it's opinion, as am I. I think the ad is an absolute turd, and I don't need to run it past some hypothetical committee to be entitled to say so - neither does The Drum.

Incidentally, I don't know if you ever read Campaign but you'll find the "active critique" as you put it is actually shorter and less detailed than the one offered here.

* This post was approved by The Drum Comments Section Approval Committee.

How did that get past ClearCast?