Gordon Young

Gordon Young, editor of The Drum, offers his insight and opinion on various matters relating to media and marketing.

20 November 2012 - 1:51pm | posted by | 4 comments

Why it's time for Sally Bercow to pay up as well as shut up after Lord McAlpine Twitter debacle

Time to pipe down: Sally BercowTime to pipe down: Sally Bercow

It could be the case with the most defendants in legal history. Lord McAlpine has 10,000 Twitter users in his sights, along with traditional media owners such as the BBC and ITV.

Just as football fans became intimate with the intricacies of the CVA thanks to the Rangers debacle, the social media community are about to learn all about libel.

No bad thing in my view. Some of them, most prominently *innocent face* Sally Bercow, may feel they are being hard done by. Surely Twitter itself should protect users from such risk? And Bercow even referred to lawyers pursuing her in one tweet as #bigbullies.

But hold on. She was part of the lynch mob that strung up the reputation of an innocent man. She, like everyone else involved, has to learn that with personal freedom comes personal responsibility. If you want to use your Freedom of Tweet to accuse somebody of a crime, then you have to be prepared to face the consequences if you are wrong.

The issue gives an interesting symmetry to the on-going debate about press regulation.

Many fear that Leveson may be about to recommend statutory controls of the press in the wake of the phone hacking scandal.

But the BBC’s role in both the McAlpine and the Jimmy Savile affairs must have given him cause to pause.

On one hand the BBC failed to unmask Savile as one of history’s most prolific child abusers. Then on the other, they all but named Lord McAlpine as a paedophile in a Newsnight report, despite the fact he was entirely innocent.

That was no doubt the genesis of the Twitter frenzy. Many would have tweeted out Lord McAlpine’s name confident in the fact that an organisation like the BBC thought he was guilty.

The BBC of course is already one of the most heavily regulated media institutions in the UK. And what this debacle proves is that regulation is no guarantee of standards. If a Director General becomes a Bystander General, or a newspaper journalist decides to break the criminal law, things will go awry no matter what regime is in place.

The current system of checks and balances - that combine self-regulation with civil and criminal law - is in fact an effective way of dealing with these failings. The real issue with phone hacking was not the system, but simply a failure to enforce it. Elements need to be tweaked – such as the law of libel and the role of the Press Complaints Commission – but fundamentally the system works, particularly because it is monitored by a free and vibrant press.

So let’s hope we can move forward into an era where both the press and citizen journalists alike – using platforms such as Twitter - always have the freedom to publish and be damned.


20 Nov 2012 - 14:08
robot75338's picture

Lord McAlpine is the author of: The New Machiavelli: The Art of Politics in Business, The Ruthless Leader: Three Classics of Strategy and Power, & The Servant.

20 Nov 2012 - 14:31
noel_young's picture

I like the phrase 'bystander general"!

20 Nov 2012 - 22:02
vrref14157's picture

Mrs Bercow ( berk and cow that sort of works)

When can we be rid of this half wit and her vertically challenged spouse?

21 Nov 2012 - 15:06
aving34675's picture

Complained about her to the BBC last year after her Guantanamo holiday camp comment on Have I got news for you, aired on Armistice day! I cant believe were all still talking about 'someones wife'. Disgraceful


Please sign in or register to comment on this article.

Have your say

Opinion, blogs and columnists - call them what you like - this is the section where people have something to say. You might agree or you might not - whatever opinion you have make your views known in comments. Views of writers are not necessarily those of The Drum. If you would like to contribute a comment piece, email your idea to opinion@thedrum.com.