Sony Ericsson advert banned for 446 hour standby time claim

An advert for Sony Ericsson’s XperiaTM X8 smartphone has been banned by the ASA after a claim that the phone had standby time of up to 446 hours was found not to be substantiated.

Sony Ericsson pointed out that the claim "Standby time (up to) 446 hours" was immediately qualified by text stating "Battery performance may vary depending on network conditions and configuration, and phone usage".

It explained that a standby time specification was an industry standard and its only intention was to allow a comparison of different mobile phones under the same circumstances. It said that factors affecting standby power consumption included network, settings, location, movement, signal strength and phone usage which was why standby time specifications of different mobile phones could only be compared in a controlled laboratory environment, and that when any mobile phone was used in real life, the actual standby time could be considerably lower depending on those factors.

It said that was why the statement regarding battery standby time was an indicative figure only and it believed the qualifying text made that clear.

The ASA acknowledged that there were factors affecting battery life, such as network, settings, location and usage and considered that the ad made that clear with the qualifying text "Battery performance may vary depending on network conditions and configuration, and phone usage".

It said: “We noted Sony Ericsson's explanation that the standby time specification had been measured in a controlled laboratory environment and we were provided with test data which showed that the phone could achieve a standby time of 446 hours in those conditions.

“However, without qualification explaining that the maximum level was theoretical, we considered that consumers would infer from the ad that the battery was capable of lasting this long during normal consumer use, subject to the other factors stated in the ad, whereas we understood that the battery life during normal use could be considerably lower. We therefore concluded that Sony Ericsson had not substantiated the claim "Standby time (up to) 446 hours" and that it was misleading.

“The ad breached CAP Code (Edition 12) rules 3.1 and 3.3 (Misleading advertising), 3.7 (Substantiation), 3.9 (Qualification) and 3.11 (Exaggeration).”

The Drum

The Drum is all about modern marketing and media. In addition this website and The Drum magazine, the company is also responsible for the Recommended Agency Register - which aims to match the right agencies with the rights clients - and MiNetwork, an organisation which aims to make independently minded agencies more successful.

All by The