10 January 2011 - 2:24pm | posted by | 2 comments

News Analysis: Football clubs need to recognise social media as mass media

News Analysis: Football clubs need to recognise social media as mass mediaNews Analysis: Football clubs need to recognise social media as mass

The use of Twitter within football has been at the forefront of several news stories in the last week, not least Liverpool FC's Ryan Babel's tweet of a mocked up picture of referee wearing a Manchester United shirt. So what should football clubs do to curb the controversy - The Drum investigates.

The Football Association will make a ruling today which could impact footballers use of Twitter as their clubs anxiously monitor their players social media presence.

Steve Downes, managing director of social media marketing agency Juice Digital said that clubs need to recognise social media as mass media and start training players on how to present themselves online. "Most football clubs have their players well versed in traditional media and back this up with contracts and media training. Clubs wouldn't allow a player to write a newspaper column without clearing it through a press office" said Downes.

He also said clubs were underestimating social media channels like Twitter. "A player’s appearance on Match of the Day is carefully controlled, but the programme has only a fraction of Twitter's full reach. Clubs need to treat social media just as highly as a TV appearance." Downes added it was not unreasonable for clubs to control a player’s use of social media, with clubs setting up accounts and providing specialist training.

Philippa Duxbury, marketing manager at the National Football Museum agreed that some players would benefit training, but dismissed the idea of an outright ban. She commented: "Like any of us in employment, footballers need to understand that when they wear a club’s shirt, they are representing that club and what they say reflects on the club."

Could social media use mirror a clubs in house code of discipline? Last year Darren Burgess, a head physio at Liverpool accused the FA on Twitter of being "completely amateurish" for refusing to substitute Steven Gerrard during an international match. Like Babel, the update was quickly removed and an apology posted, while Manchester United last year took control of Twitter accounts belonging to Wayne Rooney and other key players.

The SFA has this afternoon warned all Scottish clubs that abusive statements via Twitter and Facebook would incur a penalty for bringing the game into disrepute and it is expected that Babel will be singled out to warn other players off venting their wrath through social media.


10 Jan 2011 - 17:30
patrick_kavanagh's picture

Newcastle are already doing this:

"Newcastle United's players will shortly be given guidelines about their tweeting habits. Alan Pardew was annoyed last Tuesday when José Enrique, his Spanish left-back, informed Twitter followers he would miss the team's game at Tottenham through injury. As Enrique, happily restored to fitness for tomorrow's trip to Wigan, is a key player, Pardew had intended keeping his absence quiet until the teamsheets appeared.

"We are giving a presentation to the squad about the current format of information," Newcastle's manager said. "Hopefully we will get that right. We don't want players tweeting about their fitness on the day of games but we are not going to stop freedom of speech. It is not the Chinese republic here."


But typically in football it's about controlling all aspects of communications with the fans, separating players even further from those who make the game what it is... the fans. The Premier League is rather archaic in this sense.

12 Jan 2011 - 16:36
neale_gilhooley's picture

Not half as funny as seeing a picture of Ryan Babel wearing a Liverpool shirt.


Please sign in or register to comment on this article.

Latest Projects from the Profile Hub


Our Challenge Lifes2Good is an expanding nutraceutical...

McGraw-Hill Education

McGraw-Hill Education, the learning science company...

Sony Pictures

Papa John's teamed up with Sony Pictures for the release of...

Case Study | Bladonmore

David Ladds, Director of Bladonmore, share his insights in...

Jessica Tappin is pure gold for our client Freya Active

To launch the Freya Active AW15 collection we created the ‘...